EXPENSIVE INTERNET … DATA DEFERRED …

Digital interactions ideally lead to expansive experiences, not least for artists producing creative content. Filmmaker Tseliso Monaheng focuses on Covid-induced data disruption, through personal commentary as well as via his short film, Expensive Internets, featuring multimedia artist Andy Mkosi.  


Originally, the idea for this story was for me to learn about how the cost of data impacts upon the production capacity of cultural workers in South Africa. 

What it ended up becoming, following conversations with people pre- and post-WHO’s classification of COVID19 as a pandemic, is a report about how the high cost of data – and accompanying lag in Internet speeds for countries where cost isn’t a prohibiting factor – renders it near-impossible to deny that Internet access is being weaponized to keep ordinary Africans – and ordinary citizens across the global South – out of the loop in as far as partaking in conversations that ultimately impact their lives. 

Additionally, issues relating to the Internet only expose structural conditions such as lack of infrastructure, or the lack of maintenance in countries with sound infrastructural projects. 



Electricity shortages are a contributing factor to accessibility, as Bulawayo-based photographer Khumbelo Mpofu points out.

“Even if you’re not on [a WiFi connection], and you’re trying to use mobile data, you’ll find that when there’s no electricity in a particular area, the signal is not as good. That basically slows you down,” he says. 

This unreliability becomes a problem when he’s on assignment for any one of the international news agencies that he freelances for. 

“Sometimes you get further briefings from your editor. That’s most usually via e-mail or WhatsApp. If you can’t access those messages, sometimes, it becomes a problem. It also means [that] you can’t do your work on time, and that doesn’t look good on anyone,” he says. 



Mutli-disciplinary artist Andiswa Mkosi, who splits her time between Johannesburg and Cape Town, tells a similar tale of disruption. Hers, however, has to do with how exorbitant data prices interrupt workflow. 

“I think it was in 2019. I was uploading content for a client who was in Germany. Data depleted. I couldn’t even ask my mom to hotspot [me]. People [we live with] are buying 30 Megabytes’ worth of data sometimes. In instances like that, you need a provider that has a stable Internet connection, and it’s guaranteed that [the data] won’t deplete in the middle of an upload at 50 percent,” she says. 




Andy, with whom I’d spoken before the hard 2020 lockdown in – a period that South Africans colloquially refer to as Level 5 – also shared how she rationed her data usage throughout the year. (Parts of this are in the video at the end of this commentary).




It’s only recently that the government in Uganda has lifted a pre-election nationwide ban on Internet usage. Here in South Africa, mobile network providers have paid lip service to the recommendations in the Competition Commission’s Final Data Market Inquiry’s report – most notably the part that requires them to cut prices across all product offerings. Vodacom, for instance, only went as far as implementing it on one offering. In India, the government has shut down Internet access around New Delhi amidst the on-going farmer protests.

To Khumbelo, back in Zimbabwe, these disruptive practices can be just as detrimental for the state.

“We’ve also had challenges where, in the past, when there have been riots, the government has shut down the Internet. The last time we had such an incident was in January 2019, when we had the fuel protests. What that does is shut you out from the world. Ironically, even the government itself lost money [since] the revenue authority and other services rely on the Internet for their transactions.”

Internet access is a fundamental human right, which is why it’s important to track these conversations around usage, and around broader issues such as data privacy and how mobile network providers collude with governments to essentially oppress citizens.



Expensive Internets (Directed by Tseliso Monaheng)


All images are stills from Tseliso Monaheng’s Expensive Internets film.