THE COMPLEXION OF XENOPHOBIA

Toka Hlongwane unpicks some of the backstory to xenophobia in Johannesburg, with images by photographer Masai Dabula.

Credit Masai Dabula

When street photographer and writer, Toka Hlongwane, pitched a story about xenophobia in South Africa, he noted that it may not fit the usual tone for People’s Stories Project. True, but in working with fellow photographer Masai Dabula, he’s managed to put words as well as a historical back story to Dabula’s images. He does this by tracing some of the recent attacks on foreigners in east Johannesburg’s Thokoza township to some of the generational strife between South Africans and Africans from other countries. The deeper underlying issues of tribalism and tribal hierarchy are what Hlongwane is keen to highlight, to show that xenophobia in South Africa is multilayered and ‘can’t be dismissed with the popular rhetoric of socio-economic problems or the colonial rule aftermath that Steve Biko and Franz Fanon predicted.’

About three kilometres ahead of me, a thick black cloud of smoke camouflages the sky just after dusk. As I drive closer and closer towards Thokoza, more dark, but smaller clouds appear. My road companion Sabata shouts “bona daar, ho cha mkhukhu… le daar (look there, that’s a shack burning and there too).” The road leading towards the southern entrance of Thokoza is packed with traffic, and some cars are making U-turns to avoid the looming danger ahead.

It was evident that it must be some disgruntled residents of Phola-Park, (a section of Thokoza at the south entrance) who were fed up with not having electricity. In the five and half weeks leading up to this evening, residents of Thokoza had been without power, after their electrical substation exploded and went up in aggressive flames due to oil spillage and faulty connections. The municipality had been vague about when the substation would be fixed and when power would be restored. Initially, they said it would take two weeks, then three, then soon. More hollow promises followed from them. Thus causing a lot of anxiety among the residents, who often resorted to blocking off main roads with makeshift barricades including burning tyres, old mattresses, rocks and anything else they perceived fitting for the occasion.


Credit Masai Dabula

However, something about that evening’s protest felt melancholic. The number of burning objects and blue police lights flaring in the distance indicated that something bigger was brewing in the melting pot. Like other motorists, I made a U-turn and drove towards the northern entrance of Thokoza. As we drove towards Sabata’s house in another section of the area called Extension 2, quite sure we had averted the drama, we encountered a mob with ad hoc weapons, singing and aggressively charging towards a convenience store owned by an Ethiopian guy named Lucas. It was evident that what we thought were electricity-related protests were well-orchestrated xenophobic attacks, since they were hitting various spots of Phola-Park section, as well as Extension 2 and 5 simultaneously.

Back in 2008, the world was jolted by the sight of Mozambican, Ernesto Alfabeto Nhamuave, who was set alight in Ramaphosa – an informal settlement in the east of Johannesburg. He was beaten, stabbed, and then burnt to death. His killing formed part of the first large-scale xenophobia attacks recorded in post-Apartheid South Africa, but these were certainly not the first nor last. The complexion of xenophobia in South Africa is one of peculiar tones. It’s rooted in tribalism, colourism, as well as colonialism – and of late violence and bias disguised as patriotism peddled by politicians.


Credit Masai Dabula

Thinking back to when I was a child, I grew up knowing that I “shouldn’t behave like a Shangaan.” If someone was dressed in bright colours and their fashion taste was off, they had to be Shangaan. If one’s skin is darker in complexion they are automatically regarded as Shangaan, or dissed for being dark like a Shangaan. If you buy a soft drink called Lemon Twist, locals are quick to ask you why you are drinking icoldrink yama Shangaan (cold drink liked by Shangaans). This prejudice is embedded in our culture and language so much that it has become a knee jerk reaction to our behaviour and things we “jokingly’’ disapprove of. This can be the same prejudiced rhetoric used to kill foreigners, since the word Shangaan has been used as shorthand to describe any person from other African countries – with Lesotho, Botswana and Swaziland being the exception. One might attribute the lack of prejudice towards people of these three countries to the fact that their languages – Sesotho, Seswati and Setswana – are spoken in South Africa; yet so is Shangaan or Tsonga, but people from Mozambique always bear the brunt of xenophobia.

Also, the anti-Shangaan sentiments are linked to a specific tribal back story. 

Soshangane born Manankosi Nxumalo was a military commander of the Ndwendwe tribe who lived in modern-day Pongola in KwaZulu Natal. Led by King Zwide, the Ndwendwe tribe waged war against the Mthethwa’s in 1818. They caught and executed their king Dingiswayo, who happened to be Zulu chief Shaka Zulu’s cousin. A series of wars broke out between the Zulus and the Ndwendwes as the Zulus sought to avenge their allies’ death. The Zulus finally emerged victoriously, with most of Dingiswayo’s tribesmen killed or captured and integrated into the Zulu tribe. It is said that Soshangane was also captured and Shaka wanted to use him as a general in his army since the Ndwendwe’s army was very formidable.


Credit Masai Dabula

Most of the history around Soshangane and this era in Southern Africa is oral and there are always conflicting encounters of the same narratives. In the two different accounts of Soshangane’s departure from the Zulu kingdom, some say he escaped with a group of loyalists as he didn’t want to be integrated into the Zulu tribe, while others say at the height of Difaqane (the scattering, used by victims of the war) or Mfecane (the crushing, used by the victors’) wars, Shaka sent Soshangane on a mission to conquer the Tsonga tribe – a peace-loving nomadic cluster of tribes made up of the Ndzawu, Chopi, Kore Kore and Ronga clans – of present-day Southern Mozambique. It is said that when Soshangane arrived, he found arable land and so resorted to assimilating with the Tsonga’s. Depending on who you ask, some say when he became familiar with the ways of the Tsonga he conquered, and since they had no monarch he proclaimed himself king and formed the Gaza Empire. Others say he taught the Tsonga how to fight and defend themselves against Shaka’s troops and they named him king and called the tribe Shangaans.

Sixty years after Soshangane’s death, gold was discovered in South Africa by Afrikaaner farmers, which gave rise to an influx of migrants who came to work in the mines. Until 1904, there had been only white miners, but just after the South African War, some 64,000 indentured Chinese labourers were brought into the country. When they were repatriated in 1910, a black labour force was recruited, and most of these labourers were immigrants from Mozambique and other neighbouring countries including Malawi, Zimbabwe Angola and Zambia. When the local black workforce was introduced, its occupants came from the tribal lands across South Africa, and when these men came to the city they predominantly remained among their fellow tribesmen, often addressing each other along with other tribes by their chief or king’s name. Once the locals encountered Shangaans they showed resentment because of the Shiya’ngane urban legend of leaving their children behind while they sought work, and some tribes that had still had a bone to pick with Shangaans saw this as a perfect opportunity to ridicule their enemies.

It’s a form of prejudice that Shangaans still bear today, and because other migrant workers from neighbouring countries spoke foreign languages that most local tribesmen couldn’t understand, it became increasingly harder to discern who was Shangaan and who was from elsewhere on the continent, thus Kwere-Kwere (foreigners in South African townships) and Shangaan became shorthand for any black person who wasn’t South African.


Credit Masai Dabula

Fast forward to the height of Apartheid when communism was the biggest enemy to the regime and the capitalist world at large. Most liberation movements on the African continent were funded by Moscow and Cuba and this posed a major threat to the colonial rulers in Angola, Mozambique, Rhodesia (Zimbabwe) Namibia and South Africa. In 1975 the Apartheid government fashioned a military outfit, which was formed around displaced mercenaries from the Angolan Civil War that ended in the same year, resulting in the communist FAPLA (People’s Armed Forces of Liberation of Angola) seizing power. Most opposing FNLA (National Liberation Front of Angola) soldiers fled to neighbouring countries like South Africa searching for asylum, which was given in exchange for pledging allegiance to Apartheid South Africa. Colonel Jan Breytenbach of The South African Special Forces Brigade was granted permission to form a unit around these displaced military pros, thus creating the elite troupe of mercenaries – the 32 Battalion.

Also known as The Terrible Ones, the unit was a light inventory battalion of extreme ruthlessness consisting of black and white soldiers. This force contained two rifle companies, a machine gun platoon, a motor platoon, an anti-tank and a reconnaissance section. This unit spent most of the ’70s and early 80’s fighting and terrorizing liberation movements like Angola’s FNLA, Namibia’s SWAPO (South West Africa People’s Organisation), Mozambique’s FRELIMO, and South Africa’s APLA (Azanian People’s Liberation Army) and MK (Umkhonto weSizwe). In the mid-’80s, South Africa was a ticking time bomb, with the ANC and PAC military wings waging an armed struggle against Apartheid. Most townships in the country became ungovernable as the youth had adopted a surge of anger and violent defiance against the regime. In response to this restlessness, the government declared several states of emergencies and heightened military presence and control in South Africa’s ghettos. 


Credit Masai Dabula

By the early 1990s, the Soviet Union had collapsed and despite the 32 Battalion’s fame or notoriety for being the greatest fighting force on the African continent, countries including Namibia, Angola and Mozambique had gained independence, so there was no more action on the border wars; therefore, the South African government decided to deploy the battalion into its townships. They came to Thokoza in 1992 and on the 8th of April, the 32 Battalion attacked the community of Phola-Park, beating the residents with metal pipes, shooting and killing some members as well as gang-raping the women and children. The SADF (South African Defense Force) tried to dismiss these allegations, but they couldn’t justify the presence of the 32 Battalion in Thokoza without police. This led to the dismantling of the unit in 1993. Although the residents of Thokoza can’t remember the white soldier’s faces, they will never forget the faces of the black soldiers who carried out these heinous acts on them, and that these faces belonged to Angolan citizens; Kwere-Kweres and Shangaans. This was an age-old divide and conquer and black-on-black trick used by the colonial white man on the continent. 

There is, therefore, a stamp of historical repetition. In present-day South Africa, the attitude towards black immigrants in South Africa hasn’t changed much. The aroma of xenophobia is still heavy in the air, and although subtle for the most part, when it gets violent it becomes deadly. Most political analysts and xenophobia experts often preoccupy themselves with generic global reasons for xenophobia, like weak economic growth, high unemployment, foreigners and crime. Although these are some of the triggers of the violence exerted on black and of late Asian foreigners, they are a far cry from the actual fabric of xenophobia in the country.


Credit Masai Dabula

Violence against foreigners is not a phenomenon that just came to existence in democratic South Africa. We have always had tribal chauvinism and we have always in some way or form encouraged xenophobia and Shangaan-Kwere-Kwere hate in our households and communities. We even went as far as spending the summer of 1999 dancing to a Kwaito hit song called Fong Kong by the late Senyaka and Kamazu; a song that alleged that Chinese people sold fake shoes in South Africa. This laid the foundation for hate towards the Chinese and Asians, and we ended up calling most Asian’s by the song’s title.

Until we stop treating this hate and mis-education as footnotes, we will never get to the crux of the matter. Labelling it xenophobia will be the pussyfoot circumference that will yield no results and in turn breed more resentment among Africans since the generic reasons attached to xenophobia by experts are the exact reasons used to justify it by its perpetrators. As one angry xenophobe pointed out, “e baba these people are low hanging fruit; if we attack them the government will hear our grievances.”